The Case for Kindness
Much like gratitude, practicing kindness can make your life richer and add to your ability to truly flourish. Huge positive gains have been measured in gratitude studies, both for the study participants asked to express their appreciation and for the people who receive their thanks. “The Gratitude Letter” is a commonly used coaching activity that creates this marvelous exchange of gratitude and affirmation (Lyubomirsky et al, 2004).
Kindness fosters similar sorts of gestures and positive feelings, so you might assume that random acts of kindness create win-win situations, but you might also be surprised at the complexities at work in how people feel and why they act kindly.
Since the 1980s, researchers have conducted more than 25 significant studies exploring empathy and altruistic acts of kindness, questioning two sides of an interesting debate: (1) Do people perform acts of kindness purely for their selfish benefit—to boost their egos or avoid feeling guilty for not showing empathy; or (2) Do people act kindly from genuine feelings of empathy, making personal sacrifices for selfless and altruistic reasons? It’s a fascinating debate if you like to analyze why people feel the way they feel or do what they do. One of my go-to experts on positive psychology, Dr. Ben Dean, has explored the debate from research and practice.
According to Dean, the theory of “universal egoism” holds that every act of kindness is ultimately done for self-satisfaction. He cites Batson and others (2002) from a lengthy study in which they established three primary reasons why people perform kindnesses for their own benefit:
- Helping a homeless person or comforting a grieving friend relieves the physical and psychological discomfort we feel when someone else needs support;
- Helping someone else allows us to avoid the shame and disapproval of loved ones, friends or peers; and
- Helping someone else—especially someone most likely to reciprocate—allows us to build social goodwill and potential benefits, too.
These three explanations make sense logically, but don’t fully explain why people sometimes take great personal risk: pulling a perfect stranger from a fiery wreck or overpowering a mugger who assaults a disabled person or a child. Why are Good Samaritans so good?
Research from studies compiled over the last 30 years supports the other side of the debate: that most people are motivated to selflessly relieve the suffering of others if they can. Consider these explanations in support of this: If relieving the tension from physical and psychological discomfort was our sole aim, we would most often escape the situation and run the other direction. Time and time again, studies reveal that avoiding social shame and disapproval—social sanctions—don’t explain why we commit random and deliberate acts of kindness. Studies also substantiate that, whether we feel certain that our kindness will be reciprocated or not, we feel kindly toward others and extend a helping hand, a hot meal or often much more.
Clearly, science supports our elemental need to feel empathy for someone else’s suffering and to act kindly to alleviate it. Kindness then, like gratitude, is an emotion and an impulse to act that is soulfully human and fosters positive emotion, the potential for authentic connection with others, and a limitless spring of satisfaction and goodwill.
Be kind to yourself and others then. Naturally, you will.
With Love and Light,
Dr Mell
——————————————-
Batson, C D, Ahmad, N, Lishner, D A & Tsang, J (2002). Empathy and altruism. In C R Snyder & S L Lopez (Eds.), Handbook of positive psychology (pp. 485-498). New York: Oxford University Press.
Lyubomirsky, S, Tkach, C & Sheldon, K M (2004). Pursuing sustained happiness through random acts of kindness and counting one’s blessings: Tests of two six-week interventions. Unpublished data, Department of Psychology, University of California, Riverside.